American Idol - Season 8

[CajunMama]

I'm disappointed in tonights result.

[Brent]

Confirmed: Performance moves to Wednesday(2 hours) and Results to Thursday(1 Hour) next week due to Obama's news conference on Tuesday.

[vbhoutex]

I'm disappointed in tonights result.

Me too, even though I didn't have her in my top 5.

[southerngale]

I didn't dislike Alexis, but didn't like her much, either. Neutral, I guess, so I wasn't really disappointed, but sorry to those who liked her. I think there are a few others who should have left before her. Adam was horrible last night, but he's never going home.

[DESTRUCTION5]

I have a theory here....im thinking Judges did not save Alexis last night because the top 10 go on tour and next week they have to eliminate 2 if they saved her...Thus it would not be fair to one of them....Think?

[lurkey]

Two hours tonight . .*checks DVR to make sure Lost is being taped*

Motown tonight

Word is that they went to Detroit this week, except for Megan and Michael. They didn't go 'cause they are sick with the 'flu.. . .

[lurkey]

D5 doesn't seem to be around, no one to abuse in chat

They are doing the judges' intro again. . .blah

Songs for tonight:

Matt Giraud - “Let’s Get it On” by - Marvin Gaye
Kris Allen - “How Sweet it Is” by - Marvin Gaye
Scott MacIntyre - ”You Can’t Hurry Love” by - Supremes
Megan Joy Corkrey - “For Once in My Life” by Stevie Wonder
Anoop Desai - “Ooh Baby Baby” by - Smokey Robinson and The Miracles
Michael Sarver - “Ain’t Too Proud to Beg” by - Temptations
Lil Rounds - “Heatwave” by - Martha and the Vandellas
Adam Lambert - “Tracks of my Tears” by - Smokey and the Miracles
Danny Gokey - “Get Ready” by - Temptations
Allison Iraheta - “Papa was a Rolling Stone” by - Temptations


#1 D5 finally shows. . .and it's Matt up first. . absolutely loved it. . .

#2 Kris. . . meh. . .didn't blow me away. . . safe performance *shrugs* it works

*commercial again* *tells Brent to get into chat -- your girlfriend isn't there*

#3 Scott. . . I was afraid this was going low tempo and surprised it went up tempo. . .BUT . .singing each song like Bruce Hornsby is getting old

*steals Simon's crayons*
commercial again . . .*sigh*

posts Duke joke in chat

TMI, Paula, TMI . . .

#4 Megan . . . *groans* it's bad . . .really bad . . .go home please. . . *puts D5 out of his misery*

*yawns*

#5 Anoop I liked it. . .a bit too slow . .. . the falsetto was bit shaky at points. . .especially when he starts into it. . . .

*remembers that it is Sayid night on Lost and turns the channel to Lost*

#6 Michael meh. .. not impressive .. .. thank you, simon

ughhhhh

#7 Lil meh , like it . . but didn't blow me away . . . I think Matt was the best so far. .

#8 Adam . . . loved it . . . he can actually do something other than wannabe punk boy . . . that is good. .

#9 Danny .. . I liked it but not as good as Matt, Adam or Kris. .

#10 and the pimp spot goes to . . .Allison that was awesome. . . . the best female singer tonight. . .

Allison/Adam
Matt

Kris

Danny/Lil/Anoop



Scott







Michael








Megan --- please go home. . please

[Brent]

Matt-Awesome song choice and incredible performance

Kris-Another great song and amazing performance

Scott-Meh. I'm tired of him.

TMI Paula, lol.

Megan-OMG, my ears!!!!!!! I could not wait for this miserable song to end. Horrible, dreadful, awful, hideous. Nice eye candy though but PLEASE go home for my sanity's sake.

Anoop-It was okay

Michael-Blah! This show started off well and has come to a screeching halt.

Lil-Decent

Adam-AMAZING!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Danny-Pretty Good

Allison-Great

[vbhoutex]

Matt-one of the top 3 or 4 tonight
Kris-ok, but quit playing it safe
Scott-Not impressive at all.He's good, but not good enough.
Megan-OW!!! OW!!!! GO HOME!!!
Anoop-Very good job tonight. Liked it a lot.
Mike-Churching it up didn't help much. better than last week, but...
Lil-Meh-Not at all what anyone expected tonight.
Adam-WOW!!WOW!!! He has once again proven he will be in the finale.
Danny-one of the top 3 or 4 tonight
Allison-WOW!!!WOW!!!! Don't be surprised if it is Adam and her in the finale.

Top 5 as of tonight-Allison, Adam, Danny, Matt, Maybe Lil if she comes back as she should next week after this disaster????

[lurkey]

I think this falls in the "well duh, we already knew" category"

[DESTRUCTION5]

I think this falls in the "well duh, we already knew" category"

Whats the Dial My Idol geeks say tonight Lurkey?

[lurkey]

I think this falls in the "well duh, we already knew" category"

Whats the Dial My Idol geeks say tonight Lurkey?

Bottom three: Scott, Megan, and Michael Pretty much ones that stunk last night. . . though they rated Lil and Danny a little high . . .Matt, Kris and Anoop were better than them, IMO. . .

[Brent]

Boo! Matt/Michael/Scott bottom three, Megan safe(ugh!) and Scott is now safe. Michael better go.

[lurkey]

Boo! Matt/Michael/Scott bottom three, Megan safe(ugh!) and Scott is now safe. Michael better go.

Matt and Michael bottom two. . .


bye,bye Michael

[southerngale]

I was sad to see Michael go (local boy & I liked him), but I knew he wasn't going to win it all. He was definitely not the worst one last night, though.

[Brent]

I found the judges deliberation at the end to be totally pointless. They were never going to save Michael(and shouldn't have) and I wish they'd stop the dramatics and "fake debate" about it.

[vbhoutex]

I found the judges deliberation at the end to be totally pointless. They were never going to save Michael(and shouldn't have) and I wish they'd stop the dramatics and "fake debate" about it.

My thoughts exactly!!! Matt deserved to be in the bottom three like I need another pound added to my body!!! That is my biggest problem with AI-the voting process isn't always "fair" since some of the contestants or their friends and family go out of their way to make voting sites etc. That is how Ruben Studdard won season 2.

[Pburgh]

They were right when they said that Michael was a class act. I really liked him but he needed to go.

David, I'm with you, I LOVE Allison and really think Adam is talented. He reminds me so much of Prince.

[Ed Mahmoud]

My daughter wanted me to watch. Strictly based on cute factor, I like Allison.



Not enough that I'd ever call in to vote or anything.


I usually get my fix of Paula appearing intoxicated while watching 'Talk Soup'.

[Stephanie]

I found the judges deliberation at the end to be totally pointless. They were never going to save Michael(and shouldn't have) and I wish they'd stop the dramatics and "fake debate" about it.

My thoughts exactly!!! Matt deserved to be in the bottom three like I need another pound added to my body!!! That is my biggest problem with AI-the voting process isn't always "fair" since some of the contestants or their friends and family go out of their way to make voting sites etc. That is how Ruben Studdard won season 2.

Yup, though I love his voice. If only he went (or will go the way of) Luther Vandross musically. He really has that potential.

Look at Chris Dougherty. He was voted off WAYYYY too early. Luckily, he's a big success on his own. It's all about marketing and I don't think RCA really does a good job marketing their contestants.

Adam also reminds me a little bit of Steve Tyler of Aerosmith - his flamboyancy, and Prince, most definately. He's going to have a solid career one way or another.