American Idol

OtherHD · #1 Postby **OtherHD** » Thu Apr 08, 2004 9:53 pm

In lieu of all the Apprentice threads on the boards, I thought I'd make one for American Idol. Who all has been watching? I admit, I've always made my distaste for reality TV widely known, but I can't get enough of Idol. Who else here watches it? Is anyone else POed that John Stevens hasn't been voted out yet? He is the worst of the final 12 and yet he has NEVER once been in the bottom three, and yet, people like Jennifer Hudson who are GREAT, get screwed over. It was only until this week that she finally got recognized for the talent that she has. She had always been (undeservingly) in the bottom three every since the final 12 competition began. And I am STILL mad that Amy Adams got booted. She was one of the top 5!

:grr:

It's moments like these that make me NOT proud to be an American...they can be so STUPID at times!!

rainstorm · #2 Postby **rainstorm** » Thu Apr 08, 2004 9:55 pm

dont watch it. its the one reality show i think is dumb.

OtherHD · #3 Postby **OtherHD** » Thu Apr 08, 2004 9:59 pm

Well golly gee, I guess I shouldn't watch it then! :eek:

Stormsfury · #4 Postby **Stormsfury** » Thu Apr 08, 2004 10:02 pm

rainstorm wrote:dont watch it. its the one reality show i think is dumb.

It's Survivor's fault ... I blame SURVIVOR!!! ...

Anonymous · #5 Postby **Anonymous** » Thu Apr 08, 2004 10:04 pm

My younger sister watches it all the time. I think it's just as dumb as most of the other Reality TV type programs. Actually, I really enjoy watching the episodes at the beginning of the season to see how god-awful some of the first-round contestants are and the judges' insults, but other than that...

rainstorm · #6 Postby **rainstorm** » Thu Apr 08, 2004 10:05 pm

go ahead and watch, but nothing can top "paradise hotel"

OtherHD · #7 Postby **OtherHD** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 8:32 am

I can't be the only one here who watches the show. I know there is one other poster here who does, but we are not on speaking terms so I don't expect him/her to reply. PLEASE tell me I am not alone!

stormraiser · #8 Postby **stormraiser** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 8:41 am

I don't watch it, but that Stevens Kid is all over the news here because he is from the area.

petal*pusher · #9 Postby **petal*pusher** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 9:11 am

O.K. ....OtherHD.....gotta admit, this show has reeled me in also!

My evening time at home is very limited (teach 3 nights a week, take care of Mom on Friday's).....so just sittin' on the couch watching a show that doesn't have to make me follow along is quite refreshing!! It's fun to see how they get better each week....some of them anyway....I agree about John Stevens.....he certainly does NOT have "star appeal"! I love watching that George fella....such talent!

By the way, what does your name stand for??......p :wink:

Colin · #10 Postby **Colin** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 9:23 am

I watch American Idol...GO DIANA DIGARMO!!!!!!

OtherHD · #11 Postby **OtherHD** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 9:32 am

petal*pusher wrote:O.K. ....OtherHD.....gotta admit, this show has reeled me in also!

My evening time at home is very limited (teach 3 nights a week, take care of Mom on Friday's).....so just sittin' on the couch watching a show that doesn't have to make me follow along is quite refreshing!! It's fun to see how they get better each week....some of them anyway....I agree about John Stevens.....he certainly does NOT have "star appeal"! I love watching that George fella....such talent!

By the way, what does your name stand for??......p

lol..the HD stands for hurricanedude. Years ago when I signed up at TWC message boards, I used the name hurricanedude, not knowing there was a hurricanedude at the old storm2k boards. When I joined storm2k in January 2002, I had to use the name The_other_HD, and then shortened it to OtherHD.

Colin, I agree with you about Diana DiGarmo, but I'm kind of disappointed in the way she skipped off after being announced she was safe. The scene with Jasmine and Camille was so sweet, but Diana just skipped merrilly off without shaking hands or hugging or anything. She does have talent though, and I would put her in the top 5 along with Jennifer, LaToya, George, and Fantasia.

#12 Postby **vbhoutex** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 9:32 am

I confess!!!!! And your comments about John and Jennifer are right on!!!

What I find interesting is that if you wade through the harshness of simon's comments, he is usually exactly right in his assessment. As far as the early rounds, a lot of that is a set up just for ratings. there were contestants here in Houston that were passed over because "they had their quota of good ones" according to some of them. It could be sour grapes but I heard the young lady sing and she was good. On the other hand, I will never understand how some of those who audition can even come close to thinking they even have a voice, much less a singing voice!!!! :eek:

OtherHD · #13 Postby **OtherHD** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 9:35 am

Oh, and one thing that I am not happy about is the way many people vote. On the AI message board there is a huge thread with people saying how many times they voted for a certain person. Most said they voted over 100 times. I think that's messed up and that AI needs to have a system set up to where once you call, your number is blocked until the next week. It messes up the voting process otherwise, and is the reason horrible singers such as JOHN STEVENS are still in this thing!

#14 Postby **Pburgh** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 9:38 am

Ok, you got me - I watch it!!!!!
I think George has so much personality and man does he have a great voice.

What's the name of the red headed kid that can't sing his way out of a paper bag?? :roll:

He definitely should have gotten the boot!!!

OtherHD · #15 Postby **OtherHD** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 9:41 am

That's John Stevens. I like George too...he's easily in the top 3.

petal*pusher · #16 Postby **petal*pusher** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 10:11 am

Hmmm....thought your name had somethin' to do with "Harley's"!!

I agree about your Simon comment....although he is boo'ed and dissed, he is usually right on target with his comments......have to admire his honest approach to his judging job.

Fantasia is a good singer, but her attitude comes across as pretty sarcastic.....something that would be viewed very negative if she won......still thinkin' George is "star material"!!.....p :wink:

mf_dolphin · #17 Postby **mf_dolphin** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 10:16 am

George rules! This is I think the weakest talent group of the Idol shows so far. George may not have the best voice among the top three or so but he has by far the best stage presence IMO

Lindaloo · #18 Postby **Lindaloo** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 11:48 am

Yep, George rules!!!

#19 Postby **Stephanie** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 12:19 pm

I like George as well. I've been a viewer since AI1. To me, noone stands out this year like Kelly and Tamyra in the first season and Ruben and Clay in the second season. I can't beleive that both Johns are in it still. I feel bad for John Stevens because he's so young. JPL has a great personality, but he's not cutting it either. This year the audience is voting for personality and not talent, though this week it was good to see Camille go. She is definately suited for R&B. I liked Amy as well and I wish that she was still in the competition.

#20 Postby **Pburgh** » Fri Apr 09, 2004 12:26 pm

Stephanie, I feel sorry for John Stevens too. I think he is still there because people are taking his youth into consideration. He'll probably be the next to go. He does have a mellow and distrinctive tone to his voice - he just hasn't developed any control.

American Idol

American Idol

Who is online